Really, enough already. First I saw Free Tibet signs around the country years ago. This time I am seeing signs celebrating 50 years of the Free Tibet movement. This trip I started seeing signs for Free Palestine! Where does it end?
I understand the meaning behind the movement and agree that what occurred with Tibet at the hands of the Chinese government was not fair. Here are the facts that the “enlightened” wannabe hippies who flock to Mcleodganj and jump onto the Free Tibet cause don’t seem to seek out or ignore:
- India granted asylum to Tibetan people
- India provided free land for Tibetan people
- India allowed Tibet to set up their government inside the country
- Tibetans are some of the wealthiest residents in India, thanks to the free land granted by India, by becoming huge growers of Himachal apples.
- Tibetan NGO’s (charities) are big businesses for many Tibetans, often times not registered with the government. Photos and forged documents are shown to perspective donors highlighting the benefits of the fake programs when in reality there are no programs, the money goes directly into the Tibetan pockets.
- Tibetan Monks walk around with new cell phones and iPods, eat in local restaurants from budget to high-end, own cars (which most Indians can’t afford), and engage in rampant sexual relations with Foreign tourists openly. This is a suppressed and enlightened population?
- Luxury homes, condos and cars are being purchased at a high rate within the Tibetan communities from the money they are receiving from fake NGO’s, real NGO’s, apple farming on the free land India provided, countless items sold to unsuspecting tourists such as hats, wallets, keychains, jackets, T-shirts, etc. emblazoned with FREE TIBET.
I understand Tibetans are making the most from what they have. Running restaurants, being merchants selling Tibetan items to tourists, farming and other businesses is upstanding. My issue is Tibetans have marketed a real issue through the years into a big money making machine for themselves. This process has turned into nothing more than exploitation of their own people for which they are trying to prevent China from doing.
Also disconcerting is the amount of waste produced by the visiting Dalai Lama. Followers line the road holding incense sticks, white scarves purchased that day from local vendors and other nonsense items in hopes of giving to the Dalai Lama when he appears from his car. Indian military personnel are brought it, streets are cleaned and adorned with freshly drawn Buddhist symbols. I get that we have waste when our President visits a location, especially just with transportation. People are so consumed with the movement that they don’t even question the realities.
When your cause produces signs marking 50 years of exile, 50 years of uprising, 50 years of fighting as if it was the 50th annual Oscars broadcast, your movement is no longer a cause, it’s a business.









at 1:48 pm
I dont agree wit wat it has written on this page,
this is written by some one who dosent like tibetan people at all,
at 4:26 pm
Understandably there are some points in the post that are rather direct, yet passing along information to help inform tourists is not a bias against an entire race. I appreciate you reading and commenting and I am open to discussing this topic further.
at 3:14 am
thanks for ur respond,
why i wrote this comment is that you have written so many misunderstanding things about tibetans in india, like tibetans people receiving money from NGO office. And lot of other bad things about tibetans and monks , as i m a tibetans, and i have never received any moneyfrom NGO. For ur kind information .
i work very very hard for my living, so does our tibetans brother and sisters, and i love tibet as much as i love myself, if i have to i will die for free tibet, next time if you come to Dharamsala do try to spend times with tibetans people, then write wat you think about tibetans, not just listening to other people opinion about tibetans.
you have never know how we went through past 50 years, just try to read more about tibet,
at 12:41 pm
There are no misunderstandings, but rather, these are facts that I presented. Nowhere in the post did I claim that this applies to ALL Tibetans. I have spent time with Tibetans in Mcleodganj, but frankly, that is not the best representation of the hard working brothers and sisters you speak of. Mcleodganj is a tourist trap, a lovely place to visit, but a trap that feeds off the young and misguided foreign youths that believe they can change the world by blindly donating their parent’s money to unvetted organizations.
You have taken this post very much out of context and responded with only emotionally based attacks, not facts. I’m afraid you are so passionate about your heritage and blinded by the Free Tibet movement, that you may be unwilling to research the realities of where the funding has come from to keep the “fight” alive. While I appreciate your comments and a healthy debate, this is a site for travelers to simply research and choose where to go, what to do and what to be mindful of. Full Stop India is not for political debate.
at 4:53 am
PEACE!PEACE!PEACE!
That’s what Buddhism teaches to all of us.
Definitely there are some black sheep and Ngawang you should admit it.
I’m a Himachali and currently living in Delhi. I’ve seen Tibetan people of both states, and trust me no community is as hard-working as these people are.
But for black sheep, go for shopping to Tibetan market near Kashemere Gate in Delhi, and you will know what I am talking about. They sell garments for double the price, and after bargaining you can buy a T-shirt of Rs 500 at Rs 200 easily.
Chris! you also exaggerated some points. Offering incense sticks and khatag (white scarves)to HH Dalai Lama is a very religious custom and a show of gratitude of his efforts for well being of Tibetan people.
at 9:11 am
Prithi,
Tibetans are hard working people, just as Indians are. The post in question was not meant as a generalized lumping of an entire race but rather a heads up to unsuspecting tourists regarding a well known inside scheme to fleece traveler’s pockets. Just as in the USA, we have pockets of the population running ponzi scams and insurance fraud. Heck, just think about the hot issue of illegal immigrants using tax payer based programs.
There are exceptions to the rule in every category which you have brought up as well as Ngawang. The facts still remain that many Tibetans have made a very nice living from the help of the Indian government as well as generous support from foreign tourists.
Regarding the offerings to the Dalai Lama: I understand the cultural significance. The mention in the post was a simple commentary on how wasteful this process is. Much like organized religions around the world, the poorest people are often the most adamant supporters of customs requiring them to purchase offerings or traditional signs of solidarity. There are cracks within the world of the Dalai Lama which the world is beginning to read and hear.
My post is out there to make people at least stop and think before blindly supporting those who profit from misery. Thanks for reading and commenting!
at 12:08 pm
I totally agree with you Chris. I was trying to pacify Ngawang, so that he shouldn’t think that your post will have negative impact on foreign tourists.
at 5:27 pm
There is no comparison between Palestine and Tibet. Jews came in and created Israel out of thin air. Would this be OK for Arabs to come into America, buy land, and create an Arab state with Sharia law? Of course not. Tibetans, on the other hand, like you said were granted land from India. China, under Mao, took this land over when imperialist activities were still very much alive. If India had a problem with this, they could have stepped in. Or even the Tibetans. And, like you said, Tibet has become a greedy money machine. There is no comparison to Palestine and Israel. Palestinians were forced to live under a Jew state created out of some sort of moral sympathy from World War II. Get your facts straight and your head out of your ass. This is why the world is so messed up. There are no good leaders any more, people. You need to take responsibility for this mess too.
at 12:19 pm
Chris is not a American guy. For sure he must b Shugden party or may b chinese. Who try to create us a problem. Get a life man..and die yourself.
at 12:30 pm
Actually Tenzin, I am a born and raised US citizen. I can understand we may not agree on this subject, however, there are better, more articulate ways of expressing your opinion. Wishing for my premature death is not how you invoke thoughtful debate, nor gain sympathy for your plight.
I do thank you for reading Full Stop India.